Integrating Workflow Automation with SAP Enterprise Systems

If your organization uses SAP systems, you probably understand that it contains many things such as finances, purchasing, inventories, HR, sales orders. It is the most commonly used system of record, which is considered to contain the “true” information. At the same time, when asking the question of how the work flows within this system, you receive a combination of emails, spreadsheets, shared inbox and somebody who knows exactly what needs to be clicked.

This is precisely the area where workflow automation becomes so important. SAP stores the data. Workflow automation allows moving the work within the system and between users without manually managing its movement.

This article will help you to understand how I would integrate workflow automation with SAP.

Why Workflow Automation Should Integrate with SAP

SAP is very strong when it comes to structured transactions. This is something it handles pretty well. What it might not be that great at is handling those blurred boundaries of business operation when an invoice comes through email, there are delays due to the fact that the person responsible for the process is out of town on a vacation, and some requests require information from three different departments and two more systems.

This is how the situation goes when processes are not automated:

  • Data entered manually. Information is manually entered into SAP by someone looking at the paper or email.
  • Tardiness in the process. The request lies in the mailbox unnoticed by anyone.
  • Inconsistent systems. CRM, ticketing, e-signature, and SAP keep bits of information, but none of them has the full view of the picture.
  • Invisibility. Management is unaware of how far the purchase order or a customer request made it.

Integration of automation into SAP will solve all this without changing the system.

Why workflow automation should integrate with SAP

What is Enterprise Workflow Automation?

This one is relatively simple to define. Essentially, enterprise workflow automation is the automation of multistep business processes in an organisation, typically a large one with lots of people and departments involved and with lots of rules and approvals and auditability and security included.

It’s different from the automation of tasks within a single small team in several aspects:

  • Enterprise process automation has to account for scale, thousands of operations instead of dozens.
  • It has to be governed, which implies clear ownership, authorisations and who did what.
  • The process has to work in multiple systems, not one application.
  • It has to conform to compliance and audit requirements, particularly financial and procurement.

When done right, the process of purchase request to approved order to delivery to payment goes through SAP and other software and requires very little manual intervention, with exceptions going to the right person.

Enterprise Workflow Automation Software Choices

There are plenty of options to choose from, but let’s be realistic about the two primary ways.

Products by SAP itself. Products for automation and integration by SAP, like SAP Build Process Automation or SAP Integration Suite that work on the SAP Business Technology Platform. They may be good for those who already have extensive SAP systems, as they are made to integrate with SAP data and SAP security model.

Third-party platforms. A lot of providers of enterprise workflow automation software have connectors to SAP. They are good when there are many non-SAP systems used in business processes and they need to be orchestrated on one platform.

If I had to compare solutions, I would have looked at:

  • If it was compatible with our implementation of SAP, either S/4HANA or ECC;
  • If it respected SAP’s authorization requirements, or went around them;
  • If it allowed for business users to alter workflows, or if all alterations were to be done by developers;
  • How it managed errors, retries and audit logs;
  • What its license and maintenance fees were.

As products and licenses evolve frequently, one needs to look at the vendor’s current documentation and communicate with them directly.

How Integration Works

You don’t have to be a SAP architect, but knowing the basic methods of automation-SAP integration will make your life easier.

APIs and OData services. Nowadays SAP systems offer access to their data and capabilities via APIs. An automation tool will simply call these APIs to retrieve data, create entries, or perform any other operation. This is basically how you want to do integration.

BAPIs, RFCs and IDocs. For many mature SAP environments, which still haven’t been replaced by their modern alternatives, there are good old techniques which work well in terms of data exchange and performing business logic.

Events and messaging. In some configurations, SAP can notify about an event occurred, like a new order appeared, so that the system won’t have to poll constantly.

User interface automation. If there’s no proper interface to work with, robotic process automation can automate operations on SAP UI the same way it’s done manually. Works fine, but a bit less reliable compared to API-based integrations.

The common-sense approach: use APIs wherever you can, and rely on UI automation when you have to.

How workflow automation integrates with SAP systems

The Place for AI

And now we have arrived at the exciting part. By tradition, the process of automation is based on static algorithms. In connection with the introduction of AI into the workflow, the processes become able to handle all kinds of input problems related to SAP.

For example, AI is able to understand the variety of different invoices issued by suppliers, to extract necessary information, compare it with the purchase order and detect outliers. AI is able to classify incoming emails and assign them to relevant departments. AI is able to summarize long history of the case in order to make fast decision.

Very often you will hear people talking about AI operations workflow automation enterprise services market, which means developing market of vendors and platforms providing a combination of AI and workflow automation technologies for handling operations. In my opinion, one should be careful with all this hype. The point here is not the size of the market but rather the tool which solves the task you have in hand.

In my opinion, AI is there to interpret and prepare the job, while SAP should retain its position as the authority of the transaction.

Step-by-Step Approach

Here’s what my approach would be:

Step 1: Select one process. Select a process that is frequent, rule-based and painful, such as invoice processing, purchase requisition approval, onboarding of employees or updating of customer master data. Don’t select the most complex process to start with.

Step 2: Map the process end-to-end. Document how it works currently, including all emails, spreadsheets and workarounds. The actual process is never the same as that in the manual.

Step 3: Locate SAP touch points. Understand precisely how this process uses SAP, where it accesses or manipulates SAP data, what SAP modules are used and what data elements matter.

Step 4: Check data quality. Automated processes highlight poor data quality very quickly. Duplicated vendors or bad code will lead to failures, so fix the foundations first.

Step 5: Select integration technique. Go for APIs and other officially supported integration techniques. Get advice from your SAP specialists regarding your particular SAP version and security policies.

Step 6: Exception Handling. Determine the course of action in case of an exception – for example, in the absence of purchase order, mismatched price or unfamiliar vendor. Handle those cases through a representative who will have all the relevant information.

Step 7: Build Security Into. Create separate service accounts with necessary privileges and logging for each automated process.

Step 8: Sandbox Testing. Perform testing of the automation solution with realistic scenarios and negative data on a non-production platform.

Step 9: Pilot Testing. Start with a smaller load of transactions or one business unit and analyze performance to address any issues.

Step 10: Monitoring and Improvement. Measure performance in terms of transaction processing time, error rate, exceptions and user feedback. Conduct periodic reviews, particularly after SAP upgrade.

Mistakes I’d Avoid

  • Automating a dysfunctional process. Get it right before making it automated.
  • Disregarding your SAP team. They know the system capabilities and limitations and upgrade plan.
  • Basing the integration solely on screen automation. It can go wrong when the screen changes following an update.
  • Lack of governance. Make clear who owns the workflow, who may modify it, and how to do that.
  • Downplaying the importance of change management. People have to understand why they must change their process.
  • Omitting upgrade considerations. Your SAP landscape evolves, and your integrations have to follow.
  • Going big bang. Automate one workflow first and then proceed with others.

What Results Can You Realistically Expect?

Expectations have to be realistic. Common advantages include faster cycle times, reduced manual mistakes, improved visibility on bottlenecks, improved auditability and decreased workload of your team. All of these are accumulated as you automate more workflows. Don’t expect miracles from automation as it magnifies what you already have.

Concluding Remarks

Workflow automation with SAP doesn’t require you to get rid of your main ERP system. Instead, you need to build an environment around it so that information gets to the right person when needed, requiring minimal effort. Focus on just one process, choose proven ways to integrate workflows, design exception handling correctly, and always take care of governance and security.

My recommendation: this week, ask your team what SAP process drives them mad. You’ll have your first candidate right there!

If you need help in planning a proper integration, feel free to learn more about us at Aura Flow Tech.

Scroll to Top