Hiring a Business Technology Consultant: A Six-Week Diary

Almost all information on recruiting a business technology consultant is presented from the consultant’s point of view: his services, approach, diagrams, processes. I thought that another approach would be nice. Here is a diary of a fictional owner of a small catering company, written in the real owners’ style: tired, practical, and somewhat skeptical. It’s illustrative, not a real case, but every entry reflects a situation I’ve seen many times.

After the diary, I’ll pull out the lessons, compare the types of consultants available and share the scope paragraph I’d insist on before paying anyone.

The Diary

Week 1, Monday. Three things went wrong today. A client’s order was entered twice. The invoice for last week’s wedding still hasn’t gone out. And my kitchen manager told me, politely, that she’s spending two hours a day copying orders between the email inbox, a spreadsheet and the accounting software. We have eleven staff. This can’t go on.

I’ve been Googling “small business technology consulting” for an hour. Every site promises transformation. I’d settle for an invoice going out on time.

Week 1, Thursday. I’ve spoken to three people. One firm sent a polished proposal before we’d even spoken twice. It includes a “digital transformation roadmap” with eight phases. One independent consultant asked me a lot of questions and quoted nothing. The third said, “I’d like to watch your Tuesday before I tell you anything.”

I don’t know which I like best. The first looks professional. The third is the strangest and the most interesting.

Week 2, Tuesday. The third consultant came and sat in the kitchen for four hours. She asked who touches an order, from the first email to the final payment. We drew it on a whiteboard. It has eleven steps. Four are copying.

She said something I wrote down: “You don’t have a software problem. You have a handoff problem, and software might help.”

Week 2, Friday. She sent a one-page summary. It listed the problem in my own words, three options with their costs and trade-offs and one that she recommended: a shared order form that feeds the spreadsheet and the invoicing tool automatically. She also said, in writing, which parts of my business she thought I should not touch yet.

Nobody has ever told me what not to buy.

Week 3, Monday. I asked the first firm for a second conversation. Their reply included a new, bigger proposal. I’ll pass. Their proposal solved problems I don’t have.

Week 3, Wednesday. We agreed on a small starting project: six weeks, one fixed fee and a clear definition of “done”: a single order enters once, flows to the invoice and notifies the kitchen. I asked what could go wrong. She named three things, including the one I was most worried about: staff not using it.

Week 4, Tuesday. Setup is underway. She asked my kitchen manager to test the form before anyone else. Marta found two missing fields in ten minutes. If this had gone straight to everyone, I’d have been apologising for weeks.

Week 5, Thursday. Soft launch with two clients. One order came through the form. It reached the spreadsheet and the invoice draft within a minute. Marta looked at me and said, “That’s it?” That’s it.

Week 6, Friday. Handover day. I got a short guide, a list of every account and login, and a note about who to call if something breaks. She also suggested a three-month check-in and said I probably wouldn’t need her in between.

I asked whether she wanted to sell me a monthly retainer. She said, “Only if you find you need one.”

I’m writing this down so I remember why I’d hire her again.

What the Diary Shows

Four things stand out when I read an entry like that.

The best consultant started with observation, not a proposal. Watching the real work found the real problem. A document written after one phone call can only repeat what you already believe.

She defined “done” in plain words. One order enters once, flows to the invoice and notifies the kitchen. Anyone could check that.

She named the risks, including the human ones. Adoption is where small projects fail, and she raised it before being asked.

She was willing to say “not yet.” Advice that includes things you shouldn’t buy is the clearest sign of someone working for you.

Three Kinds of Help

The diary owner talked to three types of provider. Each has a place.

Business technology consulting firms. These are big companies with employees. They are appropriate for tasks that require more than one expert at a time, such as system migration, implementation of services in multiple locations or a heavily compliant development process. However, the process is designed for big companies, and therefore, your small business can get an unnecessarily large proposal. In case of choosing a company, you should find out who will be actually doing the job and if you’ll be working with this person only.

The independent small business technology consultant. One person, often with deep, practical experience, comfortable with budgets of small companies. They’re flexible and personal, and usually good at saying “you don’t need that.” Capacity is the risk; if they’re not feeling well or too busy, then you’ll have to wait. Ask how they deal with documenting things so that their knowledge doesn’t stay inside their head.

The part-time adviser. The consultant who works with you in an ongoing but limited capacity, functioning as a part-time technology lead. It’s good for when you have multiple systems and need ongoing decision-making. It can feel unnecessary early on.

Rather than ranking them, I’d match them to the problem. A single messy workflow suggests an independent consultant. A complicated, high-stakes migration might justify a firm. Ongoing decisions across many tools might call for a fractional advisor.

The Scope Paragraph I’d Insist On

Before paying anyone, I’d ask for a short written scope. Legal jargon is unnecessary. Instead, it requires these elements:

The problem: Orders have to be made three times.
What we will deliver: A single order form that feeds the order sheet and invoice draft, plus a kitchen notification.

“Done” is defined as: One order, inputted only once, to be transferred to the invoice draft and to the kitchen without the need for duplication by hand.

“Not to do”: Change accounting software or alter the design of the website.

Time frame and price: Six weeks, fixed price.
Handover: A short guide, a list of accounts and logins, and one hour of staff training.
Risks we’ve discussed: Staff adoption, missing fields and data quality.

If a consultant balks at writing something like this, that’s information. If they produce a better version than mine, even better.

Three Questions That Do Most of the Work

I don’t need a long checklist. Three questions reveal most of what matters.

  1. “What would make you tell me not to do this?” Honest consultants have answers. Salespeople don’t.
  2. “What happens after you leave?” You would like to have information on what people back your system.
  3. “What will we use to evaluate that we succeeded?” An appropriate response is a number or a concrete result, like time savings or fewer mistakes.

Where Automation Fits

Notice that the diary’s solution was modest: one form, a few automatic connections. Most smaller businesses get their first win with technology by integrating what they currently have rather than replacing anything. A smart consultant would identify the tiniest possible automation which accomplishes the most amount of repeatable process elimination, and then stop there.

Conclusion

A good business technology consultant isn’t measured by the size of the proposal. They’re measured by how well they understand your Tuesday. Whether you choose one of the business technology consulting firms, an independent small business technology consultant or a fractional advisor, look for observation before recommendation, plain definitions of “done,” honest talk about risk and the courage to say “not yet.”

My advice: before you call anyone, write down the three handoffs in your business that cause the most copying, chasing or correcting. That list is the best brief you can give, and it’ll tell you quickly whether small business technology consulting is what you need.

If you’d like help connecting the tools you already use and automating repetitive work, you’re welcome to explore what we do at Aura Flow Tech.

Scroll to Top